Selasa, 20 Oktober 2020

Bhutan's tree warrior: Spreading life in the world's most climate conscious nation - CNA

THIMPHU: Sonam Phuntsho was just a young boy when the passion for planting enveloped him. 

In a rural village of eastern Bhutan, he recalls the first sapling that he helped foster outside his house, from seeds he retrieved from a forest nearby.

“When you plant a tree and when you see it grow, it makes me feel alive and of course it gives me boundless, pure joy,” he said. “I planted hordes of trees around my house and beyond every single winter holiday. From that fateful day on, there was no looking back.”

Now 58 years old and retired, Phuntsho is on a mostly solitary mission to bring life to the hills around his home - the nation’s capital city, Thimphu. 

He is a tree warrior in a country with some of the most magical forests in the world. And there is much work to be done.

Bhutan-9533_mod
Sonam Phuntsho walks ten kilometres every day to plant trees in degraded forest areas in Thimphu. (Photo: Jack Board)

Bhutan is a country dedicated to environmental protection - its constitution mandates at least 60 per cent of its entire land mass be covered by forest, a target it easily meets and exceeds at the moment. 

More than half of the country is also currently reserved as protected areas, national parks, animal sanctuaries and biological corridors. 

The result is Bhutan has become a carbon negative country, largely thanks to the sinks its estimated 800 million of trees provide. Those offsets come to 8.7 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, about four times what the entire nation produces.

But as climate change places greater strain on the country’s forest resources and ecological balance, Phuntsho believes taking actions and making merit in the natural world has never been more important. 

Bhutan-9714_mod 2
Forest fires, dry weather and degraded soil has contributed to a lack of trees at Kuensel Phodrang. (Photo: Jack Board)

On land that has been left bare and barren as a result of wildfires and drying climate conditions, he gets to work each and every day. 

Phuntsho hikes 10 kilometres to reach Kuensel Phodrang, gentle hills that overlook the misty valley that holds Bhutan’s biggest city. It is a spiritual place too, home to the Great Buddha Dordenma, an enormous gold-gilded bronze statue that overlooks the city.

Phuntsho leaves at 8am with a packed lunch and a bundle of seeds and cuttings. He is a self-driven volunteer but feels duty-bound to continue his task - planting new trees and managing the land.

“Since Bhutan has sworn to keep 60 per cent of its land under forest cover for all time to come, I feel deeply motivated that I am contributing in some small ways to fulfill this promise,” he said.

Bhutan-9547_mod
Forests cover 72 per cent of Bhutan's land mass. (Photo: Jack Board)

READ: Singapore to plant 1 million trees, develop more gardens and parks by 2030

READ: Plans for 6km green connection linking Singapore Botanic Gardens to Singapore River unveiled

“The area is slowly coming back to life. I have planted more than 100,000 plants. It will take years but I know one day this hill will be bustling with forest life.”

His attitude and dedication is something intended to be instilled in all Bhutanese. 

In February, on the occasion of the Bhutanese King’s birthday, the country’s prime minister, Dr Lotay Tshering, encouraged every citizen to plant a tree, as a “true example of being a climate champion”.

Bhutan-9380_mod
Urban economics have been sacrificed to further conserve Bhutan's environment. (Photo: Jack Board)

“If one could take care of a tree, that person is sure to be taking care of his or her family’s life in the best natural way possible,” he told CNA.

“Whatever we do on a daily basis, climate change is involved. What I wear, what I eat, what I do for the day actually has a direct bearing on climate change. For generations to come, Bhutan will definitely be carbon negative and that is a little gift we can give to the world.”

The government has prohibited commercial logging and local Bhutanese are prohibited from taking fish from the rivers, killing wild animals or setting fire to forests for agricultural or clearing purposes. 

Bhutan-9615_mod
Forest fires are common in dry conditions in Bhutan. (Photo: Jack Board)

While this has allowed trees to flourish, some critics say forests are now overstocked, reducing the health of the life within it, affecting groundwater and increasing the risks of damaging fires. Grasslands and meadows have reduced and agricultural land has been constrained.

There are also arguments that using timber to fuel the construction industry would result in buildings more friendly to climate change, rather than the reliance on cement and glass that dominates Bhutan’s urban areas.

But officials are adamant that Bhutan is making the right decisions, despite the economic impacts that may result, and the law is strong in providing for forest protection. 

“If you don’t have it in your constitution, the need to exploit for commercial purposes will always outweigh whatever other priorities you have. That’s the reality,” said Secretary of the National Environment Commission, Sonam Wangdi.

Bhutan-9559_mod
Phuntsho says he intends to keep on planting trees as long as he is physically able to. (Photo: Jack Board)

“Forests are a source of livelihood for many, and even for microclimatic conditions, the forest is what controls precipitation. The more forest you have, you’ll have more regular precipitation, so that helps farming communities,” he said.

“Every citizen is a trustee of the environment who has the right to enjoy and the duty to protect. It’s written in our constitution. It imposes responsibility on each and every citizen. We have to make efforts.”

Phuntsho could not be asked to do more. He hopes his work in degraded land areas will reap results for generations to come.

“For me planting trees is deeply spiritual. Every time I plant a tree I pray that it benefits all sentient beings,” he said.

Bhutan-9770_mod
Buddhism and the merits of planting trees are closely connected for Bhutan's 'tree warrior'. (Photo: Jack Board)

“I am aware that when the tree that I plant grows, it becomes a source of home and food for hundreds of thousands of birds and insects and animals. If one tree can do that, imagine what hundreds of thousands of trees that you plant can do.” 

He added: “We Buddhist believe that helping give a life and helping support a life are two of the biggest positive deeds that you can do in your lifetime. I am beyond happy that I get to do this every day of my life. I intend to do it until my last breath”.

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMiY2h0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5uZWxuZXdzYXNpYS5jb20vbmV3cy9hc2lhL2JodXRhbi1jbGltYXRlLWNoYW5nZS1wbGFudGluZy10cmVlcy1lbnZpcm9ubWVudC0xMjU1MjY5MtIBAA?oc=5

2020-10-20 22:14:15Z
CBMiY2h0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5uZWxuZXdzYXNpYS5jb20vbmV3cy9hc2lhL2JodXRhbi1jbGltYXRlLWNoYW5nZS1wbGFudGluZy10cmVlcy1lbnZpcm9ubWVudC0xMjU1MjY5MtIBAA

Trump goes big on campaign trail, Biden maintains low profile with 2 weeks to go until election day - CNA

WASHINGTON: With two weeks to go until Election Day, President Donald Trump and Joe Biden adopted radically different strategies to secure votes - the Republican incumbent ramped up his appearances and the Democratic challenger opted to hunker down at home.

After two campaign rallies on Monday in Arizona, the 74-year-old Trump heads Tuesday to Pennsylvania, making a new push in the battleground state seen as vital to his reelection bid - although a rare appearance by first lady Melania Trump was called off at the last minute.

The former vice president, 77 - who is leading Trump in the polls ahead of the November 3 showdown at the ballot box - meanwhile did not schedule any public events for the second day running.

"Things are changing fast," Trump told the Fox & Friends program, claiming that his own polling showed Biden is "imploding."

"He's gone into hiding ... He's been there for a long time."

There is little visible evidence that the Democrat is really flagging in terms of voter support - two days before the final televised debate with the Republican president, he appears to be preparing at home.

READ: Final Trump-Biden debate will feature 'mute' button after chaotic first clash

In fact, polls show Trump down or in a tight contest in most of the swing states that decide presidential races, but he believes a combination of frenetic campaigning and scorched earth personal attacks on Biden are giving him new momentum.

Trump went on the offensive as fiercely as ever Tuesday, flooding the zone with an intense pursuit of a murky story painting Biden as corrupt, calling on US Attorney General Bill Barr to investigate his "criminal" opponent.

However, just over two weeks ago Trump was hospitalized with Covid-19 and Biden had the field to himself, hammering home his central message that the Republican leader has failed the country on managing the coronavirus crisis.

INVESTIGATE 'BEFORE THE ELECTION'

Trump is the subject of multiple accusations of sexual assault, financial improprieties, and also is the first president to run for reelection after being impeached.

However, he won in 2016 in part thanks to the success of a last minute push to sow doubt about the honesty of his opponent Hillary Clinton.

This time, he has dusted off that playbook again.

US President Donald Trump's rallies feature chants of 'lock him up' against opponent
US President Donald Trump's rallies feature chants of 'lock him up' against opponent Joe Biden. (Photo:AFP/Olivier Touron)

His 2020 attack centers on a conspiracy theory about the Biden family's business activities. Crowds at Trump's rallies have even repurposed the old anti-Clinton chant for Biden, shouting "lock him up."

According to Trump, Biden's personally troubled son Hunter sold access to his father in Ukraine and China when he was vice president to Barack Obama.

The narrative has been given new life on the eve of the election with the release of a story in the Trump-friendly New York Post, based on information supplied by Trump allies, regarding the supposed discovery of incriminating information on a laptop belonging to Hunter Biden.

Trump took his tactics a step further Tuesday when he not only called Joe Biden "a criminal" but demanded on Fox News that Barr "act and act fast."

"This has to be known about before the election," Trump said.

PENNSYLVANIA PUSH

According to a new poll from The New York Times/Siena College, Biden has a nine-point lead nationally.

Although this reflects the consensus of polls, there are outliers, including IBD/TIPP, which accurately predicted the 2016 shock result and sees a much tighter race now, with Biden only 2.3 points ahead.

Pennsylvania is one of the half-dozen states that Trump more or less has to win to hold on to the presidency. Polls show Biden ahead, though a Reuters/Ipsos poll this week showed the gap narrowing slightly.

READ: Floridians line up to cast ballots as US early voting crosses record 30 million mark

Trump's choice of Erie for Tuesday's rally matters because he won in the long-time Democratic bastion in 2016, highlighting his ability to woo the white, non-college educated, working class vote with his populist rhetoric.

Melania Trump was to have joined him in Pennsylvania - her first campaign rally in more than a year and a potential boost with the women's vote where polls show Trump in serious trouble.

But the trip was cancelled due to a "lingering cough" following her infection with the coronavirus, a spokeswoman said.

While Biden continues to try to focus on Trump's handling of the pandemic - depicting him as an irresponsible leader who panicked - the president is milking frustration in places like Pennsylvania with the economic impact of shutdowns and social distancing.

"We will never shut down" again, Trump promised Tuesday.

A key element in this year's campaign is early voting, which is at record highs amid fears about the spread of the virus. So far, some 34 million Americans have already cast ballots, according to the independent US Elections Project.

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMicmh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5uZWxuZXdzYXNpYS5jb20vbmV3cy93b3JsZC9kb25hbGQtdHJ1bXAtam9lLWJpZGVuLWludmVzdGlnYXRpb24tdXMtZWxlY3Rpb25zLXBlbm5zeWx2YW5pYS0xMzMyMjUyMtIBAA?oc=5

2020-10-20 19:18:45Z
52781131890781

Trump goes big on campaign trail, Biden maintains low profile - CNA

WASHINGTON: With two weeks to go until Election Day, President Donald Trump and Joe Biden adopted radically different strategies to secure votes - the Republican incumbent ramped up his appearances and the Democratic challenger opted to hunker down at home.

After two campaign rallies on Monday in Arizona, the 74-year-old Trump heads Tuesday to Pennsylvania, making a new push in the battleground state seen as vital to his reelection bid - although a rare appearance by first lady Melania Trump was called off at the last minute.

The former vice president, 77 - who is leading Trump in the polls ahead of the November 3 showdown at the ballot box - meanwhile did not schedule any public events for the second day running.

"Things are changing fast," Trump told the Fox & Friends program, claiming that his own polling showed Biden is "imploding."

"He's gone into hiding ... He's been there for a long time."

There is little visible evidence that the Democrat is really flagging in terms of voter support - two days before the final televised debate with the Republican president, he appears to be preparing at home.

READ: Final Trump-Biden debate will feature 'mute' button after chaotic first clash

In fact, polls show Trump down or in a tight contest in most of the swing states that decide presidential races, but he believes a combination of frenetic campaigning and scorched earth personal attacks on Biden are giving him new momentum.

Trump went on the offensive as fiercely as ever Tuesday, flooding the zone with an intense pursuit of a murky story painting Biden as corrupt, calling on US Attorney General Bill Barr to investigate his "criminal" opponent.

However, just over two weeks ago Trump was hospitalized with Covid-19 and Biden had the field to himself, hammering home his central message that the Republican leader has failed the country on managing the coronavirus crisis.

INVESTIGATE 'BEFORE THE ELECTION'

Trump is the subject of multiple accusations of sexual assault, financial improprieties, and also is the first president to run for reelection after being impeached.

However, he won in 2016 in part thanks to the success of a last minute push to sow doubt about the honesty of his opponent Hillary Clinton.

This time, he has dusted off that playbook again.

US President Donald Trump's rallies feature chants of 'lock him up' against opponent
US President Donald Trump's rallies feature chants of 'lock him up' against opponent Joe Biden. (Photo:AFP/Olivier Touron)

His 2020 attack centers on a conspiracy theory about the Biden family's business activities. Crowds at Trump's rallies have even repurposed the old anti-Clinton chant for Biden, shouting "lock him up."

According to Trump, Biden's personally troubled son Hunter sold access to his father in Ukraine and China when he was vice president to Barack Obama.

The narrative has been given new life on the eve of the election with the release of a story in the Trump-friendly New York Post, based on information supplied by Trump allies, regarding the supposed discovery of incriminating information on a laptop belonging to Hunter Biden.

Trump took his tactics a step further Tuesday when he not only called Joe Biden "a criminal" but demanded on Fox News that Barr "act and act fast."

"This has to be known about before the election," Trump said.

PENNSYLVANIA PUSH

According to a new poll from The New York Times/Siena College, Biden has a nine-point lead nationally.

Although this reflects the consensus of polls, there are outliers, including IBD/TIPP, which accurately predicted the 2016 shock result and sees a much tighter race now, with Biden only 2.3 points ahead.

Pennsylvania is one of the half-dozen states that Trump more or less has to win to hold on to the presidency. Polls show Biden ahead, though a Reuters/Ipsos poll this week showed the gap narrowing slightly.

READ: Floridians line up to cast ballots as US early voting crosses record 30 million mark

Trump's choice of Erie for Tuesday's rally matters because he won in the long-time Democratic bastion in 2016, highlighting his ability to woo the white, non-college educated, working class vote with his populist rhetoric.

Melania Trump was to have joined him in Pennsylvania - her first campaign rally in more than a year and a potential boost with the women's vote where polls show Trump in serious trouble.

But the trip was cancelled due to a "lingering cough" following her infection with the coronavirus, a spokeswoman said.

While Biden continues to try to focus on Trump's handling of the pandemic - depicting him as an irresponsible leader who panicked - the president is milking frustration in places like Pennsylvania with the economic impact of shutdowns and social distancing.

"We will never shut down" again, Trump promised Tuesday.

A key element in this year's campaign is early voting, which is at record highs amid fears about the spread of the virus. So far, some 34 million Americans have already cast ballots, according to the independent US Elections Project.

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMicmh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5uZWxuZXdzYXNpYS5jb20vbmV3cy93b3JsZC9kb25hbGQtdHJ1bXAtam9lLWJpZGVuLWludmVzdGlnYXRpb24tdXMtZWxlY3Rpb25zLXBlbm5zeWx2YW5pYS0xMzMyMjUyMtIBAA?oc=5

2020-10-20 17:03:45Z
52781131890781

Thai government to open extraordinary parliamentary session as protests escalate - CNA

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMiK2h0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnlvdXR1YmUuY29tL3dhdGNoP3Y9MXFLOTZRWTgwSE3SAQA?oc=5

2020-10-20 13:44:54Z
52781127393471

Umno chief Zahid on defensive over support for Malaysian opposition leader Anwar - The Straits Times

KUALA LUMPUR - Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi is in the firing line after declaring his support for opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim, facing backlash from leaders within his own party as well as its allies in Malaysia's Perikatan Nasional (PN) government.

The Straits Times understands that talks scheduled for Monday (Oct 19) night between the pro-Malay Muslim parties in Muafakat Nasional - Parti Islam SeMalaysia (PAS) and Umno - were abandoned at the 11th hour after a stand-off with Zahid.

Meanwhile an Umno supreme council pow-wow set to take place on Tuesday to discuss Zahid's proposal to back Datuk Seri Anwar's bid to become prime minister was also called off, with party leaders at loggerheads on the issue.

"The meeting has been cancelled after more than a third of the Supreme Council expressed their displeasure at Zahid's plan. Cracks are widening," an Umno source told The Straits Times.

The main bone of contention, say sources, was whether these parties could work with Mr Anwar, and the Pakatan Harapan pact he leads.

They object to working with PH and, in particular, its component party the Chinese-based Democratic Action Party (DAP). MN was formed to defend Malay rights and privileges, which it claimed were being eroded by PH at DAP's instigation when they were in government from May 2018 to February 2020.

The official reason for these cancelled meetings was that movement restrictions are currently in place in the capital and the surrounding Selangor state to curb soaring coronavirus infections. However, it is understood that party leaders were already present at Umno headquarters in Kuala Lumpur before the MN meeting was called off.

Some PAS and Umno leaders have publicly expressed disapproval of any pact with Mr Anwar and DAP.

"I was NOT consulted, and this is NOT my position as an UMNO MP. I want to categorically state that I do NOT support @anwaribrahim as PM. I have been consistent - NO ANWAR NO DAP," tweeted Foreign Minister Hishammuddin Hussein, a former party vice-president.

Since Mr Anwar's bid to form government was first unveiled in late September, speculation has been rife that he would be supported by a faction of Umno MPs. Mr Anwar's PH pact only has 91 MPs in the 222-strong Parliament, and he will need a minimum of 112 lawmakers to gain a majority.

He had claimed after an audience with the King on Oct 13 to have the support of over 120 members of Parliament.

Umno executive secretary Sumali Reduan denied on Saturday that the president's office issued a letter to the Palace signed by Zahid and former premier Najib Razak pledging support for Mr Anwar.

But official sources confirmed that in a meeting over the weekend, Zahid, who holds no position in the federal administration, was questioned by PAS counterpart Hadi Awang and Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin, as to why he would cooperate with Mr Anwar and DAP.

Just hours before Monday's MN meeting was cancelled, Datuk Seri Hadi wrote on Facebook a post condemning those "busy politicking during Covid-19".

"The public that is suffering from Covid-19 are confounded by political upheavals that should not be prioritised, what more multiplied until they vomit," he wrote.

Officials in the ruling PN pact have revealed to ST that in return for continuing to support Tan Sri Muhyiddin's government, Zahid is demanding a Cabinet reshuffle that enlarges Umno's role and for these appointments to be based on "the party hierarchy", which would mean the posts being awarded to his supporters within the party.

They add that Zahid is seeking to restore his grip on the party, after his authority was undermined by Mr Muhyiddin who has prioritised his own party lieutenants and Zahid's rivals in Umno since forming government in March.

But leaders of Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia have called on their president Muhyiddin not to relent.

"We would rather face an election as opposed to reshuffling the Cabinet under threat from an ally. After all, if the government collapses, the public would know that Anwar and Umno caused it," a party official told ST.

The postponement of the MN and Umno meetings buy Mr Zahid time to regroup. While Mr Anwar has not specified exactly which MPs back him in addition to those from PH, a separate letter that has gone viral indicates that he counts Umno's 39 as part of his support.

Some in PH believe that even if their planned countercoup fails, the fact that it has caused huge divisions in PN is considered a strategic victory.

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMiemh0dHBzOi8vd3d3LnN0cmFpdHN0aW1lcy5jb20vYXNpYS9zZS1hc2lhL3Vtbm8tY2hpZWYtemFoaWQtb24tZGVmZW5zaXZlLW92ZXItc3VwcG9ydC1mb3ItbWFsYXlzaWFuLW9wcG9zaXRpb24tbGVhZGVyLWFud2Fy0gEA?oc=5

2020-10-20 10:00:00Z
52781132416697

Why Beijing may want to keep Trump in the White House - Yahoo Singapore News

View photos
Relations between Washington and Beijing are as icy as at any time since formal ties were established four decades ago

Donald Trump has frustrated and enraged China during a tumultuous first term, but Beijing may welcome his re-election as it scans the horizon for the decline of its superpower rival.

Relations are as icy as at any time since formal ties were established four decades ago, with China warning it does not want to be drawn into a new "Cold War" with the United States.

Under his 'America First' banner, Trump has portrayed China as the greatest threat to the United States and global democracy.

He has launched a massive trade war that has cost China billions of dollars, harangued Chinese tech firms and lay all the blame for the pandemic with Beijing.

But another Trump triumph in November may have its advantages for China as President Xi Jinping seeks to cement his nation's rise as a global superpower.

China's leadership could be handed "the opportunity to boost its global standing as a champion for globalisation, multilateralism, and international cooperation," said Zhiqun Zhu, professor of political science and international relations, Bucknell University.

Trump has pulled America from a sprawling Asia-Pacific commercial deal and climate agreements, imposed billions of dollars of tariffs on Chinese goods, and withdrawn the US from the World Health Organization at the height of a global pandemic.

Where the US has retreated, Xi has stepped forward.

He has presented his country as the champion of free trade and a leader in the fight against climate change, as well as vowed to share any potential Covid-19 vaccine with poorer nations.

"A second Trump term could give China more time to rise as a great power on the world stage," Zhu said. 

Philippe Le Corre, a China expert at the Harvard Kennedy School in the United States, agreed an extension of Trump's 'America First' policies would be of long-term benefit for Beijing.

"(It) partially cuts Washington off from its traditional allies," he added, and that gave China room to manoeuvre.  

China's nationalists have openly cheered, or jeered, for Trump.

"You can make America eccentric and thus hateful for the world," Hu Xijin, editor-in-chief of the Global Times, a chest-beating nationalist paper, warned in a Tweet directed at the US president. 

"You help promote unity in China." 

Trump is also lampooned on China's heavily censored social media as 'Jianguo', meaning "help to build China". 


- Biden trouble -

Trump has undoubtedly inflicted economic and political pain on China.

"China has lost out enormously in its plan for trade and technology," said Beijing-based political analyst Hua Po.

In January the US and China signed a deal bringing a partial truce in their trade war that obliged Beijing to import an additional $200 billion in American products over two years, ranging from cars to machinery and oil to farm products.

Washington has also turned its guns on Chinese tech firms it says poses security threats, throwing the future US operations of video-sharing app TikTok -- owned by Chinese parent company Bytedance -- into uncertainty.

Mobile giant Huawei is also on Trump's hitlist.

The enmity also extends into defence and human rights, with Taiwan, Hong Kong and the treatment of China's Muslim Uighur minority all making waves in US. 

But China may not win much relief in any of these areas if Trump loses to Democratic challenger Joe Biden.

Beijing worries that Biden is likely to renew American leadership on human rights, pressing China on issues of the Uighurs, Tibet and freedom in Hong Kong.

"Biden is likely to be tougher than Trump on human rights issues in Xinjiang and Tibet," said Zhu, of Bucknell University.

And on tech and trade -- crucial flash points in the US-China rivalry -- it is unclear just how much room a Biden White House would have to manoeuvre. 

"Biden will inherit the tariffs, and I'm doubtful he would lift them unilaterally," said Bonnie Glaser, Director of the China Power Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

"Beijing will probably have to concede to other US demands if it wants the tariffs lifted."

China will also have to come up with convincing arguments on data security if it is to avoid more damaging bans on its tech firms.

Washington sees Huawei -- the global leader on 5G internet -- as a serious security threat.

"Politically, it will be almost impossible for Biden to reverse these policies," Fallon said.  

"Huawei has been on the US radar as a security threat even before the Trump presidency."

bar/sbr/apj/oho/kma/gle

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMiQmh0dHBzOi8vc2cubmV3cy55YWhvby5jb20vd2h5LWJlaWppbmctbWF5LXdhbnQta2VlcC0wNjMxMjY0NDYuaHRtbNIBSmh0dHBzOi8vc2cubmV3cy55YWhvby5jb20vYW1waHRtbC93aHktYmVpamluZy1tYXktd2FudC1rZWVwLTA2MzEyNjQ0Ni5odG1s?oc=5

2020-10-20 07:02:00Z
52781132646488

Despite steady popularity, Jokowi's COVID-19 policies raise questions about decisiveness and communication: Analysts - CNA

JAKARTA: As Indonesian President Joko Widodo marks the first year of his second term in office on Tuesday (Oct 20), analysts interviewed by CNA have raised questions over his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, especially in terms of taking decisive action and public communication.

However, the fact that his popularity ratings have held steady indicates an awareness among the public that the current uncertainties are not unique to Indonesia.

Jokowi, as the president is popularly known, seemed to initially prioritise the economy in his first 100 days in office.

When COVID-19 struck the country in March, the government appeared to be torn between prioritising public health and limiting the damage to the economy. This may have resulted in a lack of decisive and well-communicated approaches in managing the pandemic, said analysts.

However, those interviewed also pointed out that it is not fair to solely judge the current administration based on how it handled COVID-19, since no country was fully prepared to mitigate it.

Indonesia President Joko Widodo during an interview with CNA on Aug 6, 2019
Indonesia President Joko Widodo during an interview with CNA on Aug 6, 2019. (Photo: Timothy De Souza)

BALANCING PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ECONOMY

Those interviewed noted that there have been gaps in Mr Widodo’s handling of the pandemic, with Indonesia now having the highest number of COVID-19 cases in Southeast Asia.

Political analyst Yunarto Wijaya from think-tank Charta Politika said: “When we look back, Jokowi seemed to try to balance out between prioritising the people’s health and the economy at the same time …

“Did it work? I cannot say that it worked. Even now it is a big question because the number of infections has not flattened, it is far from the second wave. When other countries are talking about the second wave, we are still in the first.” 

READ: Active COVID-19 cases in Indonesia are on the decline, says President Jokowi

He noted that the Jokowi administration only had four months of “honeymoon period” from being sworn in until the pandemic reached Indonesian shores. 

“We know that the entire world is not in a normal condition … We see that all countries are bound to experience a slowdown, deviate from their target, and actually Indonesia's economic achievements are not that bad. Why? Because Indonesia dares to speculate by trying to balance between the economic and health sectors,” Mr Wijaya said.

READ: Six months after COVID-19 strikes Indonesia, questions linger over healthcare capacity and equipment

Public policy expert Agus Pambagio added that the government’s effort to balance between public health and the economy may have resulted in a lack of decisive action.

“Everyone is confused about how to handle the pandemic … We don’t have a firm determination, whether to prioritise health first or the economy. Since the beginning, I have always said resolve the health problems first. But the government decided to work on both and the effect is that after seven months, we cannot decrease or even flatten the (COVID-19) curve,” said the expert from think-tank PH & H Public Policy Interest Group.

Mr Wijaya noted that the current government cannot be compared directly with previous regimes, given the severity of the pandemic.

In fact, it would not even be fair to compare Mr Widodo’s performance in the past year with his achievements in 2015, the first year of his presidency, he added.

Indonesian leader Joko Widodo has resisted calls for a nationwide lockdown
Indonesian leader Joko Widodo. (File photo: AFP/Hafidz Mubarak A)

JOKOWI’S POPULARITY HOLDS STEADY

Despite the COVID-19 situation, according to research from Charta Politika, the president’s popularity appears to have been unaffected at around 60 per cent.

Mr Wijaya explained this was due to Jokowi’s decision to sign a government regulation that paved the way for regions to impose a partial lockdown to curb COVID-19 instead of a full lockdown.

The large-scale social restrictions, as the partial lockdown was known domestically, gave a legal basis for regions to shut down non-essential services while still allowing essential businesses to operate and people to commute.

In his first term, Indonesian President Joko Widodo distributed land to people, among other things.
In his first term, Mr Joko gave freehold land titles to people, among other programmes.

Mr Wijaya said that this measure was favoured by people in the suburbs as it did not affect their lives too drastically.

A survey from pollster Indikator Politik Indonesia released over the weekend showed that 68 per cent of the public was satisfied with Jokowi’s performance, while Voxpopuli Research Center released a survey earlier this month which showed that the public’s satisfaction towards Jokowi was 64.7 per cent. 

Mr Edbert Gani, a political economist from think-tank Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) said that based on surveys, more than 50 per cent of Indonesians think that the economy is in a weak state.

“But what is interesting is that the trust level towards Jokowi has not decreased drastically.”

He said this is unusual as trust in the government usually decreases as the economy is perceived as underperforming. 

“This means that people understand that this is a global situation. The current uncertainties are not unique to Indonesia, but they are shared globally,” he said.

MORE COULD BE DONE IN TERMS OF SOCIAL ASSISTANCE

Indonesia’s economic growth has been stagnant at around 5 per cent in the last few years, but the restrictions put in place to curb COVID-19 has caused the economy to contract 5.32 per cent in the second quarter of 2020.

It was the first contraction Indonesia has seen in more than 20 years and the third quarter, which ended on Sep 30, is expected to also show negative growth.

Slum area in Jakarta
An illegal slum area in Central Jakarta. (Photo: Nivell Rayda)

Analysts said that more could be done in terms of assistance for the people and addressing the debt burden.

Mr Gani said: “COVID-19 has opened the long structural problems of Indonesia. The economic structure is much dependent on the informal sector which has led the social security system to be particularly vulnerable where many workers are not protected socially.

“And this is a weakness for a long shock like a pandemic. Our system is not ready to deal with non-natural disasters,” Mr Gani told CNA.

READ: Jokowi unveils US$185 billion budget for 2021; Indonesia's GDP targeted to grow between 4.5% and 5.5%

READ: Indonesia needs major reforms to overcome economic crisis amid COVID-19 pandemic: Jokowi

The middle class is very vulnerable, he said, citing more and more people signing up for the pre-employment card programme which is meant to provide training for about 5.6 million Indonesians whose livelihoods have been hit by the pandemic. 

One programme which seems to be more effective in temporarily saving people’s livelihood is direct social assistance, noted Mr Gani.

He said even though lack of reliable data has hindered the government’s effort to utilise the programme fully, it has at least reached some people, especially those who have been classified as poor.

Mr Bhima Yudhistira Adhinegara, an economist from the Institute for Development of Economics and Finance (INDEF), expressed concern over the increased debt burden.

The government has issued Global Bonds of US$ 4.3 billion this year which will mature in 2050 or has a tenure of 30.5 years.

“This means that the government is inheriting debt to future generations,” Mr Adhinegara noted.

Scavenger in Jakarta
A scavenger resting on a pavement in Central Jakarta. (Photo: Nivell Rayda)

Indonesia has been listed as the 7th highest among middle and low-income countries in external debt owing US$ 402 billion, according to the World Bank’s recent International Debt Statistics 2021 report.

The country’s external debt burden is greater than Argentina, South Africa and Thailand.

Mr Adhinegara also claimed that the government’s economic stimulus packages are relatively small, at 4.2 per cent of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP). In contrast, neighbouring Malaysia’s and Singapore’s packages are well over 10 per cent of their GDP.

BACKLASH OVER JOB CREATION LAW UNDERLINES NEED FOR COMMUNICATION

Earlier this month, the parliament issued a Job Creation Law, which was said to create more jobs amid the economic slowdown.

However, the law was resisted by workers and students, who said that certain rights would be taken away. Some of the protests, including in Jakarta, threatened to spiral out of control.

Indonesia Labor Protests
Protesters and police face off during a rally in Jakarta, Indonesia, Thursday, Oct. 8, 2020. Thousands of enraged students and workers staged rallies across Indonesia on Thursday in opposition to a new law they say will cripple labor rights and harm the environment. (AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim)

Mr Wijaya of Charta Politika said it is important to understand that Jokowi intended the omnibus law to be his legacy. The Indonesian leader has been preparing the ground since his first term and wanted to cut red tape and create more jobs.

However, the initiative fell short in terms of communicating clearly to the public what the new law is all about, he said.

“He should call the people in order to communicate better. Not just the ministers or the party elites,” Mr Wijaya asserted.

READ: Indonesia’s new omnibus law no silver bullet for spurring investments: Experts

Mr Pambagio, the public policy expert, concurred.

The Job Creation Law revises more than 70 existing law and regulations. The government claimed it would make it easier to do business, but did not engage all stakeholders affected. 

He noted that the government does not have a clear spokesperson for the law, thus it was not communicated well to the public.

Mr Widodo has personally defended the law and said that the recent protests were fuelled by “disinformation”.

“I’ll give as an example, there is information that says the provincial minimum wage, the regency minimum wage, and the provincial sectoral minimum wage will be eliminated. This is not true because fact is the provincial minimum wage still exists," he said.

Jokowi Natuna 1
Indonesian President Joko Widodo visits Natuna, Indonesia, near the South China Sea, January 8, 2020. (Photo: Presidential Secretariat Press Bureau / Laily Rachev)

READ: Indonesian president warns not to rush vaccines amid halal concern

Analysts believe the government needs to be more transparent moving forward.

Mr Wijaya and Mr Pambagio noted that as public focus shifts to the availability of the COVID-19 vaccine, the government needs to be more transparent in terms of communication.

“The communication to the public must be clear. Whatever the policy is, that’s up to the government ... Whatever steps are to be taken, please communicate it to the public. It is better than hiding it or not discussing it. People will be confused, and then it could lead to chaos,” said Mr Pambagio.

BOOKMARK THIS: Our comprehensive coverage of the coronavirus outbreak and its developments

Download our app or subscribe to our Telegram channel for the latest updates on the coronavirus outbreak: https://cna.asia/telegram

Let's block ads! (Why?)


https://news.google.com/__i/rss/rd/articles/CBMib2h0dHBzOi8vd3d3LmNoYW5uZWxuZXdzYXNpYS5jb20vbmV3cy9hc2lhL2luZG9uZXNpYS1qb2tvd2ktZmlyc3QteWVhci1jb3ZpZC0xOS1wb3B1bGFyaXR5LWRlY2lzaXZlbmVzcy0xMzMxOTEyNtIBAA?oc=5

2020-10-20 08:54:10Z
52781132667558